Thursday, August 9, 2012

It's Hard Always Going Hard

It's Thursday, which may just be peak fatigue day of the week for me. I've had two days of Stronglifts, two days of Crossfit WOD's, two days on real rock, and one day on the climbing wall, and I'm feeling the muscle soreness and fatigue. But, today was another day to go out and train some climbing.

We went to another short, but steep climbing area near Nelson with routes that are pretty pumpy for the forearms as one of the big goals for today was to work the forearms. I led three routes, but also took a ride on three of routes. One of the rides was reasonable, as I doubt I would have finished the route on lead, but the other two were pure and simple cop-outs. I should have led them both. It's likely I would have fallen, but that's no big deal.

As I wasn't actually near falling on the other routes I led, I took four falls just for good measure. Doug was catching me a bit more softly so this time my back didn't hurt afterward. All that hurt was my pride as I am disappointed in myself for not giving two of those routes a go.

I could make all sorts of excuses about how it was bloody hot (it was), and I was pumped (I was), and fatigued (I was), but, at the end of the day, those are all excuses for not trying hard enough. 

Steep climbing, good to fall on

Wednesday, August 8, 2012

Rapelling Accidents

Another rappelling accident in the Rockies, this time a young man rappelled off the ends of his rope somewhere up on Castle Mountain. This brings the total - reported in the media (there could be more) - to three in less than two weeks. In the first, a mis-rigged rappel device resulted in a ground fall from 20 metres up, in the second, two climbers died after one apparently rappelled off the end of their rope while they were simul-rappelling, and the third is reported above.

Many climbers, and even the general public, frequently claim that rappelling is the most dangerous part of climbing, and, with the incidents in the last three weeks, one might be tempted to think they are right. However, I am not convinced this is true. Technically, rappelling is one of the easiest skills to master in climbing, and numerous back-up safety options are available. Learning to route find, place gear, build multi-directional gear anchors, and even master complex psycho-motor skills associated with making certain climbing moves are all harder than rappelling (particularly from bolted belays).

I came across this interesting article by climber Steph Abegg who took US mountaineering accidents reported in the annual publication "Accidents in North American Mountaineering" (ANAM) and presented the data from 1951 to 2006 in graphical form. Of particular interest is the chart labeled "US Mountaineering Accidents by Immediate Cause" in which only 3.2% of accidents were primarily attributed to rappel failure or error.

Of course, as always, there are problems with the data set used for this analysis as only accidents reported in ANAM enter the raw data and it is certain that many more accidents go unreported. However, even with this caveat, it is clear that rappel accidents can not possibly be the most dangerous part of climbing. In fact, if you group together falls/slips on snow/ice and rock fully 50% of accidents are accounted for.

It's tempting to think that the rash of recent rappelling accidents underlies a more serious problem in the climbing community, but, any statistician will tell you that random events are not necessarily randomly distributed and, in fact, tend to cluster.

What is disturbing is that so many climbers are unable to safely manage one of the simplest psycho-motor and technical skills that one encounters in climbing (note that none of these accidents involved anchor failure, they were all failures of technique). I'm left to wonder if one reason for these accidents is that the climbers are able to manage as long as everything is running smoothly, but, put one tiny glitch in the mix, such as lateness of the day, and they have no repertoire of tricks in the tool-bag to manage any deviation from normal.

Climber on a simple rappel
 

Tuesday, August 7, 2012

Rockies Report

Last week, we took a short trip to the Rockies for some climbing.  The thing about climbing in the Rockies is that routes can be scary run-out, particularly if you don't carry pitons (and I don't carry pitons) or loose, or both. Climbing in the Rockies you have to expect some loose rock, but loose run-out rock isn't my idea of a good time, so I find it important to pick routes carefully. Of course, if you want a real bold adventure, you could just go climb any route. However, if you are like me and want a mellow day out climbing, or want the climbing to be relatively safe, then some discernment in picking routes is a good idea.

As it turns out, we had typical Rockies summer weather (bad), so we didn't get as much climbing as we had hoped, but, we did alright.

The first day we hooked up with friends who wanted a crag climbing day so we went to the Black Band area at Tunnel Mountain. Easy approach (although it does feature the usual loose Rockies scree trail to the base) and we managed to spend the few hours that we had on the same section of wall which makes for efficient climbing. The grades are easy, the bolts plentiful, and the climbing pleasant if not spectacular.

Our second day we hiked up to Guides Rock on Mount Corey and climbed Aftonroe. Officially this is nine pitches but the climbing is all easy (nothing harder than 5.7) and the pitches short so you can easily link pitches. Climbing easy fully bolted multi-pitch routes on solid rock is great fun, and this climb is well worth doing. After rappelling off, we climbed the two pitch route Cheese Grater that is right by Aftonroe. Rated 5.8 and 5.6, the 5.6 pitch has harder moves than anything on Aftonroe, but the rock is super clean and the bolts are adequate.

Back of the Lake was our third day, but we got shut down early, by heavy rain and thunderstorms. I find the climbing there steep and technical and the routes we did felt way harder than any of the other climbs we had done grade for grade, but, sometimes you just need to time to get used to different rock.

After a rest day, we went out and climbed Beautiful Century on Nanny Goat. This climb is somewhere between 6 and 8 pitches, depending on whether or not you link pitches, and, has a spooky first pitch that you want to be solid on to lead, as, if you fall in the run-out section before clipping the anchor, you'll hit the ground from 20 metres up. I started up this pitch then backed off and Doug finished it. Funny thing about backing off, half the time, I realize I shouldn't have backed off, and the other half of the time I realize backing off was smart. This was one of those occasions when backing off was smart as a ground fall from that height is gonna be bad.

Then, as it does in the Rockies in summer, it started to rain.... 

Beautiful climbing on Aftonroe

Monday, August 6, 2012

Falling For You

They fail, and they alone, who have not striven. Thomas Bailey Aldrich.

I've just finished reading what is probably the best training for climbing book I've ever read, and I've read 'em all - Maximum Climbing, The Self Coached Climber, Training for Climbing, Conditioning for Climbing, and on, and on. What distinguishes Dave MacLeod's "9 Out of 10 Climbers Make The Same Mistakes" from the rest is that it contains no complicated self-assessment quizzes, no complex training regimes, no prescribed sets of exercises, repetitions, weight loss goals, or intricate training regimes.

Instead, in plain easy to understand prose, MacLeod points out the few common mistakes that climbers make and, with a "no bullshit attitude" warns that failure to attack these mistakes doesn't result, as we may think, in our treading water as a climber, but actually results in us regressing. Unlike his more positive American counterparts, the Scottish MacLeod is ruthless in exposing the little fabrications and rationales that we tell ourselves to avoid confronting the two real blocks that climbers face - being afraid to fall and afraid to fail.

The more time that passes while we defer attacking these two key issues, the smaller and smaller our comfort zone becomes until, finally, we are boxed onto a very small ledge indeed.

Fresh from reading "9 Out Of 10 Climbers" I went out today to tackle both my fear of falling and my fear of failing by plunging right in. Right now, I don't have time for a full climbing day, but, as MacLeod points out, climbing even a little bit will help maintain fitness, a concept he dubs "reversibility maintenance." But, as well as maintaining fitness I wanted to work on my fear of failing and fear of falling so we went to a 15 metre local crag with some well bolted sport routes which are at my climbing limit.

I warmed up by leading a couple of easier routes, then jumped on two harder routes that I've climbed many times before but never led as, most times, I fall off, even on top-rope. I made the first route with only one fall, although I felt like I was hanging on by the skin of my teeth for the last moves to the anchor. The second route defeated me. I got to the final clip - having taken three falls to get there - and just could not commit to the final moves that involve pulling over a very insecure slab on micro holds. When I repeated it on top-rope, it felt no easier, in fact, I peeled off a further two times!

So, success or failure? Given that the goal was to go out and push myself beyond the fear of failure and falling, I'd say a success. As MacLeod says "Failing to fail is the ultimate failure" in climbing as we give up any chance of reaching our full potential.

Get out there, give it all you got, and that itself will be a tremendous success.

Safe for falling sport route

Sunday, August 5, 2012

Sociopaths Among Us


I've previously confessed I'm addicted to bulletin boards, more for the interplay of personalities than anything else. Yet, despite being a bulletin board aficionado, I'm surprising naive at recognizing the power plays that some of the more sociopathically inclined individuals engage in. Perhaps, because, those of us with consciences cannot suspend our moral sense enough to comprehend the actions of people with no moral compass whatsoever.

We might be able to imagine getting angry, feeling slighted or wanting to make a point, but we can not understand the actions of one to whom other people are simply objects to be manipulated, for sport, for power, or, as one sociopath said, simply "because I can."

Spotting a sociopath is not as easy as you may think. Contrary to popular opinion, sociopaths function quite well in society, often rising to positions of power, and are not all incarcerated for heinous crimes. Instead, they walk among us glibly fabricating images of themselves as intelligent, talented, rational individuals. As they have no compulsion about truth telling they build facades of intricate lies and we seldom recognize them for what they are until it is too late.

Those with weak characters and self-delusion tendencies flock to sociopaths for the feeling of power they get when drifting behind in their wake and will frequently staunchly defend them. Perhaps these weak willed individuals are borderline sociopaths themselves and recognize that it is safer to ally oneself with a sociopath than it is to denounce them. Fellow sociopaths frequently form alliances which enables both of them to continue operating outside the bounds of normal convention.

What those of us with normal moral development must understand is that a sociopath will never change and will never abide by normal conventions, nor even the conventions that they insist we abide by. They will always be "beyond the pale." The best and safest thing you can do is to run, not walk away. Sociopaths are dangerous people. 

SOCIOPATH

Saturday, August 4, 2012

From The Gym To The Real World


Recently, we climbed a beautiful new route on Guides Rock near Banff called Aftonroe. This superb nine pitch 5.7 route climbs very clean rock and is fully bolt protected with bolted belays/rappel stations every 30 metres. Due to ease, fun, and safety, the route has become instantly popular and multiple parties can be found on the route on any sunny day. Much of the climbing is on relatively low angle, grippy limestone slabs. To descend you rappel the route. If you add together the busy nature of the climb, the low angle terrain on much of the route and the grippy rock, you have a perfect situation for using saddlebags to rappel.

Surprisingly, few climbers, particularly those schooled on short one pitch climbs or coming from an indoor climbing background know how to make and use saddlebags. I find the easiest method is to take a 30 cm draw, clip one end to my climbing harness (belay loop) and clip the other end to the anchor, then simply lap coil the rope as you normally would on a multi-pitch route but lay the lap coils over the 30 cm draw. Start, if you can, from the end of the rope, as you will be paying out from the middle first.

Once you have finished lap coiling the rope, take both ends of the 30 cm draw and clip them to one of your gear loops. You should have a "saddle bag" of rope on one side of your harness. If you are rappelling on two ropes, the added bulk makes it much easier to put one rope on your right side gear loops and one rope on your left side gear ropes both, of course, lap coiled on separate 30 cm draws. As you rappel, simply feed coils out from your saddlebags as you descend. Any length of draw would work, but, after experimentation, I concluded that a 30 cm draw keeps the coils tidy, yet allows me to quickly drop coils as I descend. The lap coils have a tendency to fall out of longer draws.

This technique works well anywhere, but is particularly useful on busy climbs (so you don't drop the rope on people climbing/rappelling below you), on low angle terrain, in windy conditions, or anywhere the rope might get hung up on descent (descents with big cracks and chicken heads, for example).

We simul-rappelled Aftonroe using saddlebags and garnered many positive comments from the other parties on the route as we passed by them. Not only did they appreciate knowing that a rope was not about to fall on their heads, but the efficiency of the set-up quickly convinced them of the utility of saddlebags.

Enjoying the climbing on Aftonroe

Friday, August 3, 2012

Simul-Rappelling Suicide


In the last 10 days, two separate rappelling accidents occurred in the Bow Valley near Canmore, Alberta. In the first, a young woman improperly rigged her rappel/belay device and fell 20 metres from the top of the cliff to the bottom resulting in serious but not fatal injuries. In the second, two people were killed while simul-rappelling a six pitch route when one climber rappelled off the end of the rope.

As with many climbing accidents, these instantly garnered attention from the "Monday morning quarterbacks", although, strangely, but possibly significantly, the first accident was virtually ignored while the second gained huge traction on bulletin boards across the web. I suspect the first, somewhat pedestrian accident, was overshadowed by the shock factor of the second.

Improperly rigged rappel/belay devices which result in ground falls are, unfortunately, all too common and seem to occur with more frequency at climbing areas that attract novices. The first incident described above occurred at a very popular beginner area, and, the climber was new to the sport. Simul-rappelling accidents are much rarer, perhaps simply because simul-rappelling is much rarer.

Many people, even climbers, are confused by what simul-rappelling means. Essentially, two climbers rappel down opposite strands of the climbing rope at the same time thus acting as a counter-balance to one another. With bomber anchors, straight-forward rappelling (from bolted station to bolted station), adequate rope length, auto-locking belay devices (such as the Gri-Gri), and two experienced climbers, simul-rappelling can be a fast and efficient way to descend long routes with many rappels. Experienced climbers can literally cut descent times in half.

However, simul-rappeling with novices, on difficult terrain (such as alpine climbing where there are no established stations) has been described as double-jeopardy, because, if one climber screws up (rappels off the end of the rope), both climbers face potential death falls.

I first learnt to simul-rappel about this time last year before a trip to El Portero Chico. Climbs at EPC are long (12 to 26 pitches) and the descent is always to rappel the route on solidly placed bolts, so simul-rappelling has the potential to, not only save enormous amounts of time, but get you down in daylight rather than dark.

After a couple of practice sessions at our local crag, my climbing partner and I felt good to go. Since then, we have safely descended literally dozens of routes by simul-rappelling. While this does not mean it is a technique to be used by everyone in every situation, there are clear instances where rappelling not only works well, but has safety advantages (getting down before dark or before a storm).

Of course, the Monday Morning Quarterbacks in semi-hysteria are convinced that simul-rappelling will, given enough exposure, lead to almost certain death. "A gri-gri is not going to help you or your partner if you go off the end of the rope, or if one of you didn't rig your device properly, or if one of you didn't buckle your harness properly or...or...or....or" one pundit gasped.

Well, sure, I could be a fucking idiot and do any number of stupid things, but, as it stands, I'm not.

Simul-Rapping at a local crag, PC, H. Mutch